
Supreme Court hears Exxon and Suncor's bid to end Boulder's climate suit; Roberts, Gorsuch and Barrett press the companies
The Trump administration argued for the oil companies, and several justices asked whether the court can review the unfinished case at all.
On Sept. 28, the Court's clerk told lawyers that Justice Samuel Alito would sit out the case, leaving eight justices to decide whether Colorado climate-damage suits against Exxon and Suncor can proceed. On Oct. 3, Alito, 76, said in a CBS interview that he weighed retiring after last term and will reconsider every year.
ContextBoulder sued Exxon Mobil and Suncor in 2018 under Colorado state law, about eight years before Monday's argument (Oct. 5). The complaint cites more than 700,000 acres of Colorado land hit by a mountain pine beetle outbreak. The Colorado Supreme Court let the suit go forward. The companies say federal law blocks it. The justices also asked both sides a narrower question: whether the court has jurisdiction (the legal power to hear the case) to review the Colorado ruling at all while the suit is still at an early stage. With Justice Samuel Alito recused, a 4-4 tie would leave the Colorado ruling in place, and Boulder's suit would proceed.
CBS NEWS10 sources
